Cope Environmental Center – Centerville, Indiana

Skip to primary content
  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
    • WHO WE ARE
    • STAFF & BOARD
    • MEDIA
      • SOCIAL MEDIA
      • VIDEOS
      • PICTURES
      • NEWSLETTER
      • BLOG
    • TOUR
      • PLAN YOUR VISIT
      • SUSTAINABLE EDUCATION CENTER
      • SUSTAINABLE BUILDINGS & POLICIES
      • CHILDREN OF INDIANA NATURE PARK
    • EVENTS CALENDAR
    • RENTALS
  • JOIN
    • BECOME A MEMBER
    • VOLUNTEER
    • SPONSORS
    • WAYS TO GIVE
    • EMAIL UPDATES
  • ANNUAL EVENTS
    • BIRD-A-THON
    • FAMILY EARTH DAY CELEBRATION
    • FALL FOLIAGE 5k/10k
    • FAMILY MAPLE SYRUP DAY
    • THE GALA
    • GET OUTSIDE CHALLENGE
    • GREENERY WORKSHOP
  • PROGRAMS
    • UPCOMING PROGRAMS
    • VIRTUAL PROGRAMS
      • #100DaysofCope at CEC!
    • SCHOOL PROGRAMS
    • SUMMER ADVENTURE PROGRAMS
    • TODDLER TIME
    • INDIANA MASTER NATURALIST
    • INITIATIVES
      • BICENTENNIAL INITIATIVES
      • COMMUNITY EVENTS
        • WAYNE COUNTY CHALLENGE RACES
        • ALTERNATIVE GIFT FAIR
        • ENVIRONMENTALLY SPEAKING TV
        • GET OUTSIDE-GROW!
  • RESOURCES
    • ANIMAL RESCUE & OTHER ?’s
    • RECYCLING INFORMATION
    • COMMUNITY SUSTAINIBILITY
    • PERSONAL SUSTAINIBILTY
    • KID’S CORNER
      • NATURE CHILDREN
      • NATURE PLAYSCAPE
February 22, 2012
  •  
  • 0
  • Blog
  •    
  •    

Frog Dissection: A Rite of Passage or A Passage to Extinction

We have officially entered the age of technology.  I do not say this because even third grade students have their own iPhones, and not because some classes at American high schools have abandoned textbooks and now rely on laptops.  I say this because recently I discovered that some schools are going virtual when it comes to frog dissections.  Now, I know that this is only a brief unit in a middle school science class, but as a recent news cast on Channel One News pointed out, it is a “rite of passage.”  Younger students know that their older brothers and sisters have been able to dissect and examine their very own frogs in class and they wish to live to tell this story to their younger siblings as well.  So, after viewing the new method of dissection, I began to wonder:  why? And is it really better?
First, I had to look at the facts:  1/3 of all amphibians are endangered and a majority of frogs used in dissections come from the wild.  I am 100% for saving endangered species, so this fact is substantial for me.  So, why not just grow them on farms?  Well, the problem with this is that these lab-grown specimens often carry infectious diseases that they can spread to natural populations.  Neither method is going to save many of this fading species.
Another important fact is that the cost, according to a teacher in this same news report, is $500-$1000 less per year to do the lesson online.  With this economy, I get that, too.  These facts seem to be enough to convince me, but one aspect of the new method that weighs heavily on my mind comes from the famous Chinese proverb, “Tell me and I’ll forget; show me and I may remember; involve me and I’ll understand.”  If students cannot perform the dissection with their own hands, I fear that they will not receive the complete lesson.  The virtual dissection “tells” and “shows,” but it does not “involve,” which is my main concern with this.  So, the debate becomes difficult for me, an animal-lover and protector of all species.
The simple solution would be to outlaw frog dissections all together, but I have a hard time coping with such a loss of tradition.  I have not yet completely decided my stance on the issue, though I admit the continuance of a species is far more important to me than one lesson in science class; however, I would love to know what you would have to say!  Should we continue frog dissections in our local school systems, or should we join the technological age? 
If you would like to view a video of this news cast for more information, please visit: 
Channel One News Frog Dissection Video
I would really appreciate your feedback!
-Erica
February 22, 2012
  •  
  • 0
  • Blog
  •    
  •    

    Thanks to our Corporate Sustainers

    • Reid Health
    • First Bank Richmond
    • Brady Ware and Company
    • Wayne County Foundation
    • Stamm Koechlein Family Foundation
    • Perfect Melodies
    • Belden Wire and Cable Co.
    • West End Bank
    • Quigg Fund
    • Earlham College
    • Barnhizer & Associates, Inc.
    • Meijer
    • Hill’s Pet Nutrition
    • Radford’s Meat Market & Deli
    • Stults Family Dentistry
    • Natco Credit Union
    • Thor Construction Company
    • Johns Manville
    • Boston Bever Klinge Cross & Chidester
    • Wesler Orchards
    • Logue’s TLC Pet Hospital
  • donate
    donate_buttonYour gifts support efforts to improve the local environment, enhance local environmental education opportunities, and promote responsible resource use throughout our region!

    u_stream you_tube facebook twitter

    Home | About Us | Events | Programs | | Resources | Contact |

    Cope Environmental Center ~ 1730 Airport Road, Centerville, IN 47330 ~ 765-855-3188

© 2015 Cope Environmental Center | Website created by Web Canopy Studio Inbound Marketing Team